Fiori Variant management : Transport request pop-up is not coming

[former_member575393]

Hello Friends,

When I am trying to create variant in SAP Fiori for list, I am able to create a variant but is not asking me for Transport request and which is required for transporting the variants from one system to another. Please help me to whether do I need any Authorization or any setting missing in the system.

Thanks in advance.

Regards,

Rajesh

[MioYasutake]

Does your user have role SAP_UI_FLEX_KEY_USER?

[former_member575393]

Yes this role is assigned to my user id with /UIF/KEYU = 'X'.

[junwu]

what variant you are talking about?

if you just select a few column and want to save as variant using that variant management control, then no tr needed.

if you try adapting your app and save a variant, then you will need tr.

[former_member575393]

Thanks for reply friends.

I am talking about selecting a few columns and want to save as variant. But in this case also previously it was asking TR. You can also refer the below blog for the same, in which it shows the pop-up of TR.

https://blogs.sap.com/2018/08/23/fiori-variant-management-set-a-variant-as-default-to-all-users/comm...

So I don't understand where I am missing as it is not asking the TR.

[former_member138784]

is this problem resolved?? if yes how??

[Hal64]

Please take a look at this blog:

https://blogs.sap.com/2022/03/16/sap-fiori-for-sap-s-4hana-new-options-for-managing-views-for-filter...

Beginning with SAP_UI 7.56 the logic was changed:

• Public views can be created locally in the current system/client
  • Public views can be used by everyone
  • Public views created locally are not transportable

• Key users using Adapt UI, i.e. UI Adaptation at Runtime:
  • Can create and save public views that can be used by everyone
  • Can create and save public views restricted to selected business roles, i.e. create role-specific views using the Adapt UI feature
  • Can set views as the default view for every user who has not yet set their own default view
  • Views created using Adapt UI can be transported

[Dharmasish]

There's a design change since SAP S/4HANA 2021, as you can find in the SAP Note - 3170812 - Creating a Public Variant does not prompt for a transport request - FES 2021+ - SAP for Me
Quoting from SAP Notes: 
"Starting with release SAP S/4HANA 2021 there are two kinds of public views. Public end user views and public key user views.

Public end user views are created outside of UI adaptation and are local (non-transportable). Therefore no transport pop-up appears anymore when you create a public view outside of UI adaptation.

From now on transportable public views can only be created within UI adaptation (and legacy public views that are assigned to a transport can only be updated/deleted within UI adaptation). They can be assigned to a transport during publication of the UI adaptation (which happens when you press 'Publish' inside UI adaptation)."

[martin_zaman]

Hi rajesh.maripeddi ,

do you have a solutions for this? I have the same problem.. the popup for the transport request is not shown.

[emp27]

As per my understanding, TR pop-up will only come for custom developed app, and not for standard fiori app.

(I haven't tried it myself, but I have a similar use-case, and I am researching.)

[martin_zaman]

It's also not coming for custom developed apps. My Scenario is for my custom developed app.

[shwetanargachhe]

Hi Rajesh,

When you set public default it get recorded under transport which can be used for next environment .

Validate below points you are in development box and you have required authorizations no error log in su53.

There are separate level of authorizations to manage variant in sap same apply to fiori as well.

Try to use different customer naming for variant name convention.

If access is already provided check Su3 user own data and parameter if default transport has been set or you already added this into transport se09 and hence it is recording under same open Transport.

Regards,

Shweta

[former_member575393]

Hello Shweta,

Thanks for your inputs. I have tried with public default still it was not recorded under transport.

And there are no errors as such in Su53.

Regards,

Rajesh

[junwu]

if it is your custom app, why you need that?

if you want some column to be displayed as default, why not just code your view in that way?

[former_member575393]

Hello Jun Wu,

What you said right, but we need to display columns as the business user so we need to create the variants and which they will select accordingly. Thats why we are creating variants in dev and want move them to PRD using TR.

[junwu]

if just columns, let’s say business want column a b c.

Why not you just initially display column a b c in your app?

Why bother using variant?

[former_member575393]

But if other user want only column b c then he has to hide the column a manually. So if variants are created then it will helpful for user. So variant creation is not the issue but the transport pop-up which used to get earlier is not coming now. So not sure where we are going wrong.