Can we run MRP in IBP

[ravik9525]

Hello Team,

We are not able to run the MRP in S/4HANA because of some constraints like multiple BOM but looking to implement IBP for demand planning now. So, what should we do? We should first rectify the issues and run the MRP in S/SHANA or IBP will take care it. Can we run MRP in IBP?

Thank You

[former_member27]

Hi, ravik9525,

Welcome to the SAP Community! Thank you for visiting us to get answers to your questions.

Since you're asking a question here for the first time, I'd like to offer some friendly advice on how to get the most out of your community membership and experience.

First, please see https://community.sap.com/resources/questions-and-answers, as this resource page provides tips for preparing questions that draw responses from our members. Second, feel free to take our Q&A tutorial at https://developers.sap.com/tutorials/community-qa.html, as that will help you when submitting questions to the community.

You should also make sure your e-mail notifications are turned on for "Comments and answers to my questions and questions I follow" at #communications -- so you won't miss any replies to your question.

In addition, I recommend that you include a profile picture. By personalizing your profile, you encourage readers to respond: https://developers.sap.com/tutorials/community-profile.html.

Now for some specific suggestions on how you might improve your question:

* Share screenshots of what you've seen/done (if possible), as images always helps our members better understand your problem.

* Make sure you've applied the appropriate tags -- because if you don't apply the correct tags, the right experts won't see your question to answer it. That also means making sure you don't include unrelated tags. Members frown on over-tagging if the content isn't relevant to their interests, as the post will show up in their Q&A feeds and they get annoyed when the question isn't really about a tag that they follow.

Should you wish, you can revise your question by selecting Actions, then Edit.

One last thing: If you're interested in connecting with community members, please pay a visit to our new Welcome Corner. You'll need to sign up, but it's a great way to interact with peers and get to know other experts!

I hope you find this advice useful, and we're happy to have you as part of SAP Community!

All the best,

--Dedi

[riyazahmed_ca2]

Hi Ravi,

Yes Indeed..

But in IBP, we don't call it MRP, rather Supply Planning Algorithm(namely Heuristics and Optimizer).

MRP has lots phases such Demand Management(with versions), Safety Stock Update, MRP live(to generate Receipts) and so on..

In IBP also, we do have spaces to perform Demand Management and Safety Stock update . But they are maintained as Separate entities. From IBP perspective, We can associate only the Supply Planning with MRP.

Procurement Planning as well as Production Planning can be done very better than MRP considering the appropriate Sourcing Ratio maintained in proper Master Data.

Best Regards,

Riyaz

[somnath_manna]

MRP in SAP IBP is possible in IBP S&OP and Response & Supply module in the form of Heuristics and/or Optimiser engine`. MRP is not a capability of IBP Demand component that focuses on generating demand forecast by statistical means from history data and further enhanced by planners.

BTW if you are not able to run MRP in S/4HANA due to multiple BOMs (not sure about the scenario) then it will not get solved in SAP IBP. IBP is planning application that has its own master data which is integrated with S/4HANA so that planning and execution are aligned.

[mohanbihari00]

If possible can you let me know the disadvantage or advantages of running MRP in IBP vs S/4HANA?