Enterprise Resource Planning Blog Posts by SAP
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
2,609

Introduction

In this blog, we will discuss about the new Balance Validation process that is delivered with S/4HANA CE2502. The following Fiori apps are part of this release:

In the new Balance Validation process, you can also create a new task by using the app "Define Balance Validation Task" under Manage Your Solution (F1241) > Configure Your Solution > Application Area: Finance Sub Application Area: Corporate Close > Data Processing.

Additionally, you can import or export the rule group assignments using the following Fiori app:

Transition Process

The toggle 'FINCS_BV_ADAPTATION' should be switched-on to view the above apps and also to activate this new Balance Validation process. Please follow the below note for the migration process:

The steps of the migration is explained with screenshots in the attached file of the above note.  Also, the steps to activate the toggle for 2SL and 3SL systems are different. Therefore, refer to the attachment of the above note: "ActivateFeatureToggles_2SLand3SL" .

Is it possible to create a new Task?

Yes. You can refer to the below video that explains the creation of Balance Validation task.

harivenkatesh_s_0-1738509359255.png

As you can notice, apart from Cons. Unit and Cons. Group categories you can define a new task based on accounting. Here are the  details about Standard tasks that are delivered through content:

  • S0080 - Balance Validation in Accounting
  • S1080 - Balance Validation at Consolidation Unit Level (Reported Data)
  • S1180 - Balance Validation at Consolidation Unit Level (Standardized Data)
  • S2980 - Balance Validation at Consolidation Group Level (Consolidated Data)

How to create a Rule Group?

The rules can be defined using the app "Define Validation Rules" and those rules can be added in the Rule Group as shown below.

harivenkatesh_s_2-1738510099716.png

You can Navigate to "Define Validation Rules" from this app as shown in the below screenshot.

 

harivenkatesh_s_2-1738514776012.png

Rule Group Assignment

It is mandatory to assign the Tasks to the Rule Group. The existing Validation Methods are migrated to the rule group as explained in the SNOTE "3553668 - Group Reporting: Migration of new Balance Validation Process". You can refer to the below video that explains the Task assignment to Rule Group:

harivenkatesh_s_0-1738511283518.png

What are the steps to attach the Task to Monitor(s)?

The tasks that are created using the "Define Balance Validation Task" app can be attached to the Monitor as shown below.

harivenkatesh_s_0-1738512483833.png

It is also possible to execute the Tasks  in the app "Run Balance Validation and View Results" as shown in the below screenshot.

ExecutionApp.png

How is the new Solution better than the old one?

The new Balance Validation process has the following benefits:

  • You can define a new task by choosing one of the Task Categories and run the rule definitions either in Group Reporting or in Accounting as a data source.
  • The performance is optimized and the memory consumption has relatively improved
  • It is now possible to define a maximum of 6 Group By fields
  • All Balance Validation tasks can be executed in one app: Run Balance Validation and View Results. 

Concluding with Additional Links

Please feel free to share your thoughts by commenting on this blog. Also, we can use this blog as a communication tool for any clarification that you require on this topic. You can also follow my profile for more content on analytical application and Balance Validation for group reporting. I would recommend posting your questions by specifying the tag: “SAP S/4HANA Finance for group reporting”

Define Balance Validation Tasks | SAP Help Portal

Balance Validation Tasks and Task Categories | SAP Help Portal

Working with Balance Validation Rules and Rule Groups | SAP Help Portal

Manage Balance Validation Rules and Rule Groups | SAP Help Portal

Assign Rule Groups for Balance Validation | SAP Help Portal

Run Balance Validation and View Results | SAP Help Portal

 

13 Comments
HengyeZhu
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hello Hari,
Thanks for sharing this new feature. Regarding "run the rule definitions either in Group Reporting or in Accounting as a data source", just would like to know how to specify whether the data source is ACDOCA or ACDOCU?

Best Regards,
Hengye

harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hello Hengye,

You can pick the Task Category: "Balance Validation in Accounting" while creating your task. Refer the Video under the section "Is it possible to create a new Task?".

Regards,

Hari

cfaustm3
Active Participant
0 Kudos

I'm not sure if it's just me, but when I try to play any of the videos in a regular or incognito browser session it's asking me to login.  Once I login with my universal ID or own company's Microsoft (SAP partner) credentials, I'm then not authorized to view.

Chris

harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hi Chris,

Can you check again?

Regards,

Hari

0 Kudos

Hi @harivenkatesh_subramanian

I have the same problem as @cfaustm3 

Thanks,
Arnold

arya_02
Newcomer
0 Kudos

Hi,

I am also facing same issue. Please let me know how this can be resolved.

Thanks,

Aarti

 

harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hi @arya_02 ,

Can you now check?

Regards,

Hari

Srinivasa10
Discoverer
0 Kudos

@harivenkatesh_subramanian 

First, I would like to convey my regards and appreciation for sharing this valuable information. It has been truly helpful.

I have a few clarifications that I raised with SAP Support regarding the new features and the Balance Validation Task process. To gain clarity, they asked me to refer to your blog by sharing the link, which I found informative and appreciated your effort. However, after reviewing your videos, I still find some aspects unclear. If you don't mind, could you please look into these and provide clarification? Your insights would be greatly appreciated.

Question:

1) In your video, you directly navigate to the 'Manage Your Solution' app and land on the page where you can filter the "Application Area" and "Sub Application Area" for data processes, and find the "Configure" option under 'Define Balance Validation Task'. However, in my case, we don't reach this page directly. Instead, we see the message "The business configuration of this tenant is managed by SAP Central Business Configuration," which provides two links: one redirects to the SAP Help page, and the other to the SAP Central Business Configuration page. After selecting the relevant option, we still cannot find the filter option to configure the 'Define Balance Validation Task'. Instead, we see the "Configuration" option, which shows the same options as the Implementation page (Display IMG: Authorized Activities page). We are unable to locate the "Define Balance Validation Task". I have explained this issue in a ticket to the SAP Support Team as well.

2) According to KBA 3553668 and the SAP Help page, it is mentioned that "we need to toggle the feature for Balance Validation (FINCS_BV_ADAPTATION) in the configuration activity 'Activate Features.' However, we cannot find this in the system.

Page:https://help.sap.com/docs/SAP_S4HANA_CLOUD/90c07e91c7a64f328be3fd6b48955b13/e01c5fc486f145be8f90f44c...

and in the SAP page they mentioned to "Activate Feature" which I was unable to find you followed this in the video ( I may consider this may automatically activated or backend enable to demonstrated this Video which I apricated) but I couldn't able to get the clarity on this and I was unable find in your video as well, Am I missing something to understand here?

3) I tried to drill down to get more information when i couldn't able find these option to enable it and If found the below page where SAP mentioned detailed about 'Activate Feature" 

SAP Page: https://help.sap.com/docs/SAP_S4HANA_CLOUD/b249d650b15e4b3d9fc2077ee921abd0/3e94fcc37b42433b97d6aef0...

Regarding the mentioned in the "NOTE" - Do you have any inputs here, Im keen to understand how this process happen in your above "Demo" case and How it differs for customers. If you agree with the "Note", Do you have any time line when this will be activated to customers and will we receive any notification or communication regarding this?. Im unable to get clarity which they mentioned on the " At Certain Point". if you have any information Please share the same.

4) The following SAP page they mentioned to we can find the "Define task for line item validation" in configuration activity, But we are unable to find this in our system. I believe this may be related to the Pre-requisite above page and 'Activate feature' steps which I mentioned above.

URL:https://help.sap.com/docs/SAP_S4HANA_CLOUD/ee9ee0ca4c3942068ea584d2f929b5b1/998dafecbd6a41ef8a75c2b0...

SAPURL: https://help.sap.com/docs/SAP_S4HANA_CLOUD/b249d650b15e4b3d9fc2077ee921abd0/826e3120d0cd43d4a5cf75a9...

 

5) SAP saying that it will deprecated Data Validation App in future release in the below page as part of 2502 upgrade.

https://help.sap.com/docs/SAP_S4HANA_CLOUD/ee9ee0ca4c3942068ea584d2f929b5b1/c0abeaddeb504c1c9365917e...

Related to this, I have a question: will the deprecation of this app impact other apps like F8365, F2635, and F8364, which are indirectly linked to Data Monitor and Consolidation Monitor? I believe these apps serve as alternatives and can be navigated to individually. Once we run Data Monitor and Consolidation Monitor, the task log refers to the same pages of the above apps that are linked. I'm checking for any potential impact on this point?

6) With the introduction of new balance validation apps as part of the 2502 upgrade, will there be any additional rules delivered as part of the Best Practices content? Will the existing standard validation rules undergo any changes? I read on the SAP page that existing rules will be migrated. Will this happen gradually based on the note mentioned on the 'Activate Feature' page, or will they be automatically migrated once we toggle the 'Balance Validation Process' or enable it?

Thank you for your time

Srinivasa.S

harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hi Srinivas.S,

Thanks.

Regarding "1", "2" and "3", you need to check this at your end for the roles. For. eg. the link that you have provided in "3" already have a pre-requisite.

"4" is regarding Line Validation which is out of scope of this blog.

For "5" the old apps are deprecated for GR for the current cloud release and will be removed in the upcoming release.

Regarding "6", you can refer to the snote mentioned in the blog regarding migration. The note has an attachment explaining it with the screenshot.

Regards,

Hari

Srinivasa10
Discoverer
0 Kudos

@harivenkatesh_subramanian  Thank you for your response. I appreciate it.

However, I'm still not clear on the specific answers to my questions, despite my efforts to provide detailed information. I will follow up with the SAP Support Team as I have an open ticket with them.

Thanks again.

bowen_cao
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Are AMDP still used in the new validation engine? able to debug?

takashiro
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert
0 Kudos

Hi @harivenkatesh_subramanian ,

Thank you very much for the useful information.

Please let me ask you about S0080 - Balance Validation in Accounting.
What are the benefits of having validation of accounting data in Group Reporting, especially when after accounting data are already released and their amounts are translated to group currency in Group Reporting (ACDOCU)?

According to the migration steps described in Note 3553668, S0080 - Accounting Data Validation - is located at the end of Data Monitor tasks.  (I'm assuming this is the best practice, am I correct?)
What is the point of having accounting data validation after all tasks (such as manual postings and currency translation) are done?

takashiro_0-1744689708538.png

Regards,
Takashiro

 

harivenkatesh_subramanian
Product and Topic Expert
Product and Topic Expert

Hi Takashiro,

The accounting task is for Unreleased data. This is about having an additional validation to check the data before releasing it and validate the same (you validate the data before it enters ACDOCU).  If you are not interested in running in the data Monitor you can run it in "Run Balance Validation and View results" app, as Data Monitor is optional.

Regards,

Hari