Application Development Blog Posts
Learn and share on deeper, cross technology development topics such as integration and connectivity, automation, cloud extensibility, developing at scale, and security.
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
andrea_olivieri
Contributor
14,687

See the UPDATES section below for change log

Let's check with X-it RAY Eye

In all upgrade projects in which I was involved I prepared a checklist of standard modifications and implemented userexits.

This kind of analysis performed before the upgrade, as well as give an overview of the system complexity, is helpful to prepare the testing sessions and identify a dangerous situations such as the missing call to an exit routine.

Standard tools?

The question is: how do I get a list of these customizations with minimal effort? Which are the available SAP tools?

The standard modifications can be identified using the transaction SE95 (Modification browser) that is, in my opinion, the most effective tool for this type of analysis.

But for the userexit? Is it possible to draw a map of all exit routines active in SAP ERP before an Upgrade ?

There are different types of exits in an ERP system and many tools that you can use to perform an analysis, but the result can not be achieved in a short time ...

Let’s start with the cataloguing ...

Userexits and VOFM Routines

The Modification browser is helpful if you have to look up at the implementations of include Userexits and VOFM Routines

It's not a simple task, but it is better than search the userexits among the transport requests or recognize “custom” VOFM form routines by browsing directly in the transaction VOFM...

Inside transaction VOFM you have to:

Select the Category Group

Select the Custom Routine...

and finally access to the source code

Field-Exits

Fortunately for the Field-Exits the manual effort is reduced to the minimum because there is the standard report RSMODPRF

The function key "Edit FM" allows to access directly to the source code

Validations and Substitutions Exits

Managing the Validation Exit and the Substitution Exit from the maintenance transactions can become extremely boring!!!

It is necessary to explode all validation/substitution steps 'till you find a step that contains an exit routine...

Otherwise, there are reports RGUGBR31 (Validation Directory) and RGUGBR32 (Substitution Directory) but they are not interactive reports

So the formpool must be determined into the view V_T80D

Customer Exits, Screen Exits and Menu Exits

Customer Exit, Screen Exit and Menu Exit  are managed by transaction CMOD where the situation is slightly better.

Again, in order to access to the source code of the exit many steps are required.

First of all you need to select the active projects; so from CMOD transaction select in the menu: GOTO -> FIND

Then deselect the "Inactive" enhancement component checkbox

and for each project selected you have to jump to the assigned components and to the implementations

Select the project...

Access to the components list...

And then jump to the implementation...

But this is not enough, another double click is needed in order to browse the source code of the exit...

Business Transaction Events (BTEs)

Active Business Transaction Events can be reached by transaction BERE but again many steps are required!

Run the report with the checkbox "Only BTEs with active Products" selected...

Then select the event from the list...

and finally check whether the active component has inside custom elements...

Last but not least BAdI Implementations.

The Modification Browser transaction (SE95) returns the list of BAdI implementations regardless of activation status (On/Off) but I personally prefer the Respository Browser (SE84) because is possible to select "Only Active" implementations

The selection result...

double-click to browse the implementation...

and then to the source code.... 😞

I would like an ABAP that...

Customers and colleagues often asked me if I knew a single tool that lists all the active userexits. I always answered no, proposing as approach the list of steps shown above.

Across the years I have tried to collect and automate (the first version dates back to the release 3.1I) every step of analysis in an ABAP program, but I never had time to optimize the code, so I always quickly adapted the same source to the various releases, making it unreadable and impossible to share.

One day my colleague sergio.ferrari2 (SAP Mentor Alumni) asked me: "Hey Andrea, why don't you take a look to the Abap SNIF?"

I must be honest, I understood everything by that name...

What's SNIF?

Finally the SAP has developed a kind of "Exit Browser" that avoids launching dozen of transactions in the system (excluding the various checks).

I investigated thru the implementation of this program concluding that even if the idea is wonderful and the program is useful it could be enhanced to include other type of exits And now I’m glad to share with the great SDN Community my own extended version of the SNIF that detects all types of missing exits.

X-it RAY EYE was born

X-it RAY Eye means ... X-Ray Eye + X-it (= Exit) =>  X-it RAY Eye

Thus the abap that I would like to share in this blog is the "son" of the SNIF program, because it uses his "architecture" with the difference that extends the search to the following types of exit:

  • Include USEREXITS
  • VOFM Form Routines
  • Exit for VALIDATIONS
  • Exit for SUBSTITUTIONS
  • SCREEN EXIT
  • MENU EXIT
  • CHANGED KEYWORDS

The ECC Version of X-it Ray Eye extends the search to the enhancement implementations:

  • SOURCE CODE Enhancements
  • FUNCTION Enhancements
  • CLASS Enhancements
  • BAdI Enhancements

Some of these items are not properly ABAP, however I've collected them in the tool.

Selection Screen:

Output results:

Navigation:

Download results in Excel:

I summarize briefly the main features:

  • The X-it Scanner detects only the active implementations of existing exit routines developed in the customer name range with the exception of include userexits and Vofm routines
  • For the VOFM routines the "customer" name range is determined by the group indicator
  • The original section of the "BAPI usage" by custom programs has been removed
  • In the X-it Scanner version for SAP R/3 Enterprise 4.7 and SAP ECC 5.0 the new concept of Enhancement introduced by ECC 6.0 is out of scope
  • Original language: EN English

Out of Scope:

  • Screen Variants & Transaction variants

Versions:

  • ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER for SAP R/3 Enterprise and SAP ECC 5.0
  • ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER60 for SAP ECC 6.0

Related Content

Relevant SAP Notes

Special thanks

I would like to thanks my colleagues @ Techedge:

sergio.ferrari2 (SAP Mentor Alumni) for his advices (Related Weblogs: how many lines of custom ABAP code are inside your system? )

and vincenzo.gala my friend and SAP Admin @ Bayer Business Solutions for his support during the unit test phase in rel. 4.7 Enterprise.

How to install?

Download the nugget file from here and import it in your SAP system using SAPLink.

Then goto your inactive object list and activate all objects

At last, run ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER by SE38 and... Scan'em All!

I hope you like it.

UPDATES

9-Nov-2011   abapexitrayeye CodeExchange project born

29-Nov-2011 Check for the available releases at https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/releases/viewall/1212

29-Nov-2011 Please check the fixed issues section for solutions of little bugs

21-Jul-2015 I set up a repository in GitHub; you can download the ABAPexitrayeye here.

23 Comments
Former Member
A very good work Andrea!
This toll will be very helpfull to me.
Thank you!!!

Silvio Miranda
Rocky
Explorer
0 Kudos
This looks like a great tool. I can't wait to try it out. Thank you so much for sharing.
rvinod1982
Contributor
0 Kudos
Hi Andrea,
You have done a great job!! Thank you so much


Regards,
Vinod
Former Member
0 Kudos
Thanks for you efforts.
former_member182371
Active Contributor
This is what´s SDN all about.
Thanks for sharing your work and making the life of developers easier.
Thanks again.
JimSpath
Active Contributor
0 Kudos
Andrea:

  Interesting approach to code analysis.  I am curious about a couple aspects here:

1) How much does this overlap what the Solution Manager Solution Documentation Assistant, or the SAP Code Inspector do for code reviews?

2) I'd like to see this content in the SCN wiki, so that we can cross-reference to other approaches, as well as add success stories.  Do you think this topic belongs under development, or under Basis?

Jim
andrea_olivieri
Contributor
0 Kudos
I Jim,
Thanks for the question.

The ABAP that I developed extracts only a list of all active user-exits and there is no overlap in terms of analysis with the Solution Manager and its tool like the Custom Development Management Cockpit or Code Inspector that analyses the single statement.

Regarding a possible creation of Wiki section I could say that it belongs to the category "development", but the "X-it Scanner" is composed of many sub-objects (24 include and 18 dynpro) and due to the complexity of the object in my opinion is not suitable.

Ciao.
Andrea
Former Member
0 Kudos
Andrea,
I'm using at customer side your tool on SAP ECC 5.0 and I'd like you to be aware that on this release since the enhancement framework is missing, I had to use ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER because ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER60 needs enhancement framework to work fine.

I guess you'd have to extend the compatibility of ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER for all release up to ECC 5.0, not only 4.7

Nevertheless, it's working fine and it's very helpful to discover all custom modifcations.

Thanks a lot for this utility!

Ciao
andrea_olivieri
Contributor
0 Kudos
HI, Ermanno
thanks for the suggestion.
In fact, the X-it scanner version for release 4.7 ( excluding the Enhancement Framework)
should work fine up to the release 6.03.
I updated the "Versions" section of the blog by specifying the compatible releases.
Andrea
Former Member
0 Kudos
Very useful. Thanks a bunch.
alejandro_bindi
Active Contributor
0 Kudos
Thank you very much for sharing Andrea! This is very useful, both the program and the compilation of methods to manually access each type of exit implementation.

I'd like to know if you think it would be possible to downport the program to work on a 4.6c R/3 release...so far I searched for class-based exceptions usage and found a single one, which could be removed.
Did you try to perform such a backport?

At the site I'm at we're preparing for an upgrade and this tool would be a great help...
andrea_olivieri
Contributor
0 Kudos
Hi Alejandro,
I have not planned to implement in the short term a version of the X-it scanner compatible for the release 4.6C mainly for 2 reasons:

1. Unavailability of a development environment
2. SAPLink does not work in that release, then we should use a transport request.

I’ll perform the backport during the next upgrade project.

Thanks .
Andrea
former_member156446
Active Contributor
0 Kudos
The first thing I liked in the project is the name and ofcourse the tool is a must have in all Dev's inbox 😉
Former Member
0 Kudos
Hallo Andrea,
I think you did a great job to save our money and time.
I imported both versions (4.7 and ECC 6.0) to my SAP Trial 7.01 but got an error message during activation because T001Q is missing. What should I do?
Regards
Markus
andrea_olivieri
Contributor
0 Kudos
Hi Markus,
I'm sorry, but the tool was designed only for SAP R/3 Enterprise and SAP ERP.
Many objects used by the X-it Scanner tool do not exist in SAP NetWeaver 7.01 Trial Version.

Andrea
anupam_anand
Participant
0 Kudos

Hi Andrea,

This is an absolute delight.I was looking up for a similar lookup document for a long time.

This is really very helpful.

Thanks,

Anupam

Former Member
0 Kudos

Hi Andrea,

I am unable to find the nugget file at https://cw.sdn.sap.com/cw/releases/viewall/1212.

Please advice.

Thanks,

Jaya

mayank_agarwal7
Explorer
0 Kudos

Not sure if this nugget is still available for everyone?

andrea_olivieri
Contributor
0 Kudos

Dear All,

ABAPexitrayeye is now integrated in the Automated Note Search Tool (ANST) and in the Custom Code Management Cockpit (CCMC).

For this reasons is quite useless to continue the development of this tool.

 

However, I set up a repository in GitHub; you can download the ABAPexitrayeye here.

Best,

Andrea

st_bk
Member

Dear Andrea,

the scanner is a pretty tool to find user-exits.

Now I found 3 bugs which i have fixed in my system an i wanted to inform you about that.

Here I read your message about ANST and CCMC.

May you explain what does that mean?

I found some documentation in the web and tried somthing out, but ANST is for some issues nice but not so compact. In your scanner, you have fast an result about all exits. In ANST you have to wait long for the result of one transaction.

I was'nt able to test CCMC because i don't have access to our solution manager. But the documentation seems not so simple like your scanner.

Best regards,

Stefan

00fuhailan
Member
0 Kudos
Hi Andrea,

 

In your link here

The only available version is ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER60, but I have syntax error when try to activate it. Could you please share the place where I can download ZSDN_EXIT_SCANNER?

Thanks.

 

Best regards, Hailan
0 Kudos
Hi Andrea,

Also having syntax error here from GitHub version 1.2...

"Type "BAMX_SOURCE_ANALYSIS_TABLE" is unknown."

Am on S4 Hana 1709.

Best regards,

Sue
dagni
Participant
0 Kudos

I have uploaded the program to abapGit, if anybody is still interested.

https://github.com/MDagni/user-exit-scanner

 

Labels in this area