topic Re: customizing req vs workbench request in Application Development and Automation Discussions

customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:43:40 GMT

Hello All,

Can any one explain what is the difference between them?

Thanks,

Vibha

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:45:00 GMT

hi,

1. Customizing Request: This request is generated if we are doing configuration changes to meet the scenario.

2. Work Bench Request: This are normally development Request or request which are generated during customization such that it impacts all client on the same server.

Change Request / Transport Request carries out the changes in the other server, when it is imported to it & we need not repeat the configuration in other servers, other than development server.

Customizing request is the one created through any configurations

Workbench request usually gets created by abap programmer, or if any tables are updated.

Customising request is the request generated when you do any configuration changes.Ex.creating new sales off.and assigning it to Sales area.

The flow is you define and assign in DEV Server and later on move it to QAS and then PRD,i.e.,DEV~~->QAS~~-->PRD.

When you drill down the request,it will show all the details of changes,you can easily find wheather it is Functional or Tec.

Workbench request is concernd to ABAP

Whenever you are creating any new condition tables,this request is of the nature Workbench request and not customizing request

Hope this makes the doubt clear,encourage by rewarding points

Regards,

Ram

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:45:34 GMT

<b>Workbench Requests</b>

When you change a Repository object of the ABAP Workbench, a query window appears in which you need to specify a Workbench request. You can only save the changes if you have assigned the object to a change request.

Workbench requests and the tasks assigned to them are normally used to record changes to Repository objects and Customizing for all clients. However, you can also include client-specific Customizing.

Whether the changes to Repository objects are transported depends on whether a transport route is defined from the current SAP System for the package of these objects. From the system settings, the system automatically determines whether the change requests are transportable and to which target system they should be transported.

<b>Customizing requests</b>

Customizing requests record client-specific Customizing settings made in a single client (the source client of the request).

Automatic recording of configuration activities in the Customizing work for a client can be activated or deactivated for each client with Client Control. If automatic recording is active, a query window appears when you change Customizing settings, asking you to specify a Customizing request.

Whether Customizing requests are transported or not, does not depend on the objects entered, as is the case with Workbench change requests. The Customizing requests in an SAP System (or in a client if you use Extended Transport Control) are either all transportable or all local, depending on the system setting. The system uses the standard transport layer to determine automatically whether the change requests are transportable and to which target system they should be transported. However, you can change this manually.

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:45:34 GMT

Hi,

Customizing request is for configuration entries in a table..

Workbench request is for program objects,DDIC objects..etc..

Thanks,

Naren

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

anversha_s — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:45:36 GMT

hi,

There are two types of Customizing change requests:

Customizing request

Customizing requests contain changes to client-dependent tables.

Workbench request

Workbench requests contain changes to client-independent tables.

You can monitor the change requests by project in the project management. The Transport requests tab contains the following functions for the current client:

Activate CTS functionality

As prerequisite for creating change requests. When the CTS functionality is active, the pushbutton label changes to Display CTS project data. When the CTS project is finished, the pushbutton label changes to Reactivate CTS functionality.

Assigned CTS requests

Go to Transport Organizer request overview, where you can create requests for a project.

CTS project object list

The project object list is unchanged. When the customizing project is finished, the complete object list can be exported.

CTS project status switch

Sets the project status switch.

End CTS project…

End your customizing project. You can reactivate it later.

See transport control by project for further information about the Change and Transport System (CTS) for customizing projects.

http://help.sap.com/saphelp_erp2005/helpdata/en/09/88f330db9911d2b41a00609419f767/frameset.htm

Regards

Anversha

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 04:47:08 GMT

Hi,

To be simple....

Workbench request , developments (like coding) will come under work bench rquest.

Customizing request: , if any screen customization is done, this will be saved under Customizing request.

Revert back if nay issues.

Reward with points if helpful.

Regards,

Naveen.

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 05:28:19 GMT

hi,

Changes to cross-client Customizing objects and to Repository objects are recorded in Workbench requests

In workbench request .... it can be programs(repository objects) and cross client data (ie not specific to one client).

Changes to client-specific Customizing objects are recorded in Customizing requests.

Customer customized data designed for a specific client is transported to another client using customizing request. Most of the cases these requests are something like changing values in tables (that too client specific).

Hope it helps

regards

pritha

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 05:54:50 GMT

Hi Vibha,

Customizing requests will store requests when the functional consultants make configuration settings... Like assigning an SAP Script to an output type and all...

When ever abapers work on module pools, reports, sap scripts and other such abap coding tools, work bench requests are created...

Regards,

Mamata.

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 05:57:40 GMT

Hi,

Go thru the link below:

Regards

Kannaiah

Re: customizing req vs workbench request

Former Member — Thu, 31 May 2007 06:03:11 GMT

thnks