topic Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists in Application Development and Automation Discussions

SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

qmacro — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 07:57:50 GMT

This is the voting thread for the SAP Community Coding Challenge 2. For more information, please see the following material:

- SAP Community Coding Challenge Nr.2 - the challenge description

- SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 – Update - an update following the submission deadline

- SAP Community Coding Challenge Nr.2 - Solutions - the recording of a live stream looking at some of the submitted solutions

- SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 – Contestants - a list of the successful contestants

There are four finalists. In this question thread you will see four answers, one for each finalist. In each of these four answers you will see:

- a link to the finalist's profile

- a link to the specific solution submitted (check out this link to see the solution)

- one observation (from all those that we made on each and every submission)

Note that it was not easy picking a short list of finalists - there were so many absolutely great submissions. Well done to you all!

Use the answer voting mechanism to choose the one solution you believe should be the overall winner. And, as before, please remember that this is all for fun and education. We are all winners here because of the great knowledge sharing!

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

qmacro — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 07:58:56 GMT

Finalist maheshkumar.palavalli

Submission as a part of his learning journey into JS and beyond.

https://repl.it/@MaheshKumarKum3/ccc2-2

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

qmacro — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 07:59:56 GMT

Finalist huseyin.dereli

Detailed submission tied together with a UI5 web components front end.

https://sccc2.glitch.me/

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

qmacro — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 08:01:07 GMT

Finalist christian.drumm

Use of Ramda library functions.

https://repl.it/@ceedee666/SAP-Community-Code-Challange-2-3

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

qmacro — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 08:04:28 GMT

Finalist alexander_frank

Inspired a super fast entry from murbani.

https://repl.it/@AlexMFrank/ccc2

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

MarcelloUrbani — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 08:26:33 GMT

Liked the idea a lot, but I think it was pushed too far, for instance you don't really need an isOdd, and I hate testing the same condition twice. Also, it's rather slow notwhitstanding memoization

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

MarcelloUrbani — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 08:27:02 GMT

Loved the trampoline, was a close call 🙂

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

maheshpalavalli — Wed, 10 Jun 2020 16:22:13 GMT

Congrats guys, Great solutions, there is something new to learn from every finalist !

Re: SAP Community Coding Challenge 2 - Finalists

AlexFrank — Tue, 16 Jun 2020 13:21:22 GMT

This was Marcello's solution: https://repl.it/@marcellourbani/longestCollatzfastest

The most impressive thing to me was that he managed to extract the Collatz logic in a one line function while having this fast execution time. Also it looks more JavaScripty to me than my solution.