topic Re: ABAP Expression FILTER not working in Application Development and Automation Discussions

ABAP Expression FILTER not working

Former Member — Tue, 08 Mar 2016 06:43:31 GMT

Hello folks,

I really like the new expressions in ABAP. Especially the "FILTER" Statement. But unfortunatly, it doesn't work everytime. If you start this code here, it will result in an endless loop at the filter statement.


TYPES: BEGIN OF ty_s_itab,
          artgrp    TYPE char4,
          datum_von TYPE dats,
          datum_bis TYPE dats,
        END OF ty_s_itab,
        ty_t_itab TYPE SORTED TABLE OF ty_s_itab
 WITH UNIQUE KEY artgrp datum_von datum_bis
        .

 DATA: lv_datum TYPE dats VALUE '20160304'.

 DATA(lt_data)  = VALUE ty_t_itab(  ( artgrp = 'EC  '
                                    datum_von = '20160304'
                                    datum_bis = '20160501 ')
                                  ( artgrp = 'EC  '
                                    datum_von = '20160101'
                                    datum_bis = '20160301 ')
 ).

 DATA(lt_filter)  = FILTER #( lt_data WHERE artgrp = 'EC  '
                                        AND datum_von <= lv_datum
                                        AND datum_bis >= lv_datum ).

 LOOP AT lt_filter INTO DATA(ls_filter).
   WRITE: ls_filter-artgrp, ls_filter-datum_von.
 ENDLOOP.

Could someone verify this or, even better, have an explanation for it? I don't understand it...

Kind regards

Bastian Stritt

Re: ABAP Expression FILTER not working

ThomasKruegl — Tue, 08 Mar 2016 16:19:42 GMT

I can confirm this, endless loop at the filter statement. I have no explanations but a bug in the filter implementation.

I played around a bit:

- change second condition to "AND datum_von < lv_datum" (removing the 😃 -> code executes

- remove third condition -> code executes

- only remove "=" in third condition -> still broken.

- change lv_datum to a variable with another value for the third condition -> code executes.

No idea what exactly the problem is.

regards,

Thomas

Re: ABAP Expression FILTER not working

ChristianGnter — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 10:47:37 GMT

quite interesting.

Maybe Horst Keller can bring some light into the dark

Re: ABAP Expression FILTER not working

retired_member — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 12:30:22 GMT

In a 7.50 system, the process is hanging.

In a 7.51 system I get the runtime error ABAP_ASSERT.

-> Clearly a bug in the FILTER expression, Forwarded to development.

Re: ABAP Expression FILTER not working

retired_member — Fri, 11 Mar 2016 09:48:28 GMT

Indeed, it is a bug that will be corrected in an upcoming kernel patch.

Thanks for notifying!