topic Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro in Application Development and Automation Discussions

Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Mon, 21 Jul 2014 11:13:57 GMT

Hey there ABAP developers,

I just want to ask if you can give me one or two minutes of your attention for two poll questions.

At the moment I´m writing my master thesis about the development of a monitoring tool in ABAP. One of my bigger chapters is about the decision, which programming paradigm should be used for new development projects in SAP. And another important one is about WebDynpro vs. classical Dynpros.

Because of the fact, that I can´t create any polls in here, I just started this discussion and hope for many replies .

It would be very nice if some of you could give me an answer to the following questions (only 2 ), so that I can maybe use the result of this poll in my master thesis, if there are enough responses.

1. What percentage of new development projects are you developing in ABAP Objects? (Not to be considered small reports that just runs for only one time)
     A. 0 %
     B. less than 25%
     C. 25% - 49%
     D. 50% - 75%
     E. more than 75%

2. Which GUI technology do you prefer?
     A. Classical Dynpro
     B. WebDynpro
     C. Business Server Pages (BSP)
     D. others (please mention)

I want to thank you in advance for answering the questions,

Best regards,
Christoph

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

SwadhinGhatuary — Mon, 21 Jul 2014 11:49:40 GMT

hi,

Now a days arround 50% abap report are developed by using abap objects as manitaince and development are easier comparatively with Classical Approach.

Come to Second Quest

Depend upon req. if Application no access through web we go for Classical Dynpro.

if it req web acess report we go for Webdynpro Abap/java or BSP

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 08:46:17 GMT

Hey Swadhin,

thanks for your answer!

regards

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 09:42:04 GMT

Hi,

Present SAP Implementation projects are very rare, maximum projects are support and up gradations only .

If they want Implement the SAP newly , defiantly they should creating ABAP Objects.

Why Because ABAP Objects are Object Oriented Concepts, so, for future reference and re usability..etc .

Now Come to the First Quetion.

if it is implementation project ABAP Objects are 25% - 49%.

if it is Support project ABAP Objects are 25%

Now Come to the Second Quetion.

Depend upon Reqmnt, but Most of the Applications are Webdynpro . i.e 70%.

Remaining 30% All ( BSP and GUI ....Etc..)

This is my opinion.

Sambaiah.Paidipelli.

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

SuhaSaha — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 11:40:36 GMT

Hello Christoph,

I think it would be better if you created a poll in the ABAP forums instead of starting a discussion.

BR,

Suhas

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 12:47:35 GMT

Hey Suhas,

yes I think a real poll would be much better, but I don´t have the permissions to add polls as content to the ABAP Development Space,... or which ABAP forums do you mean?

best regards,

Christoph

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

SuhaSaha — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 13:35:49 GMT

Hi Christoph,

When you click the "Create" button, don't you see the "Poll" option?

BR,

Suhas

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Tue, 22 Jul 2014 14:03:33 GMT

Hey Suhas,

yes, I see it, but like the Tooptip in my Screenshot says, I can´t choose a place because I don´t have access to add content to the place, or the type of content I´ve chosen (poll) is not avialable. But I think I just have no permission to create a poll in the ABAP Development Place.

thats because why I created a discussion.

regards,

Christoph

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Wed, 23 Jul 2014 05:54:23 GMT

Hi,

Thanks for your answer!

regards,

Christoph

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

claudia_bolch — Wed, 23 Jul 2014 13:09:11 GMT

Hi Suhas,

only moderators are able to create polls, normal "people" aren't.

explained this here:

Regards

Claudia

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

SuhaSaha — Wed, 23 Jul 2014 13:33:48 GMT

Thanks Claudia I have created 2 polls for Christoph:

BR,

Suhas

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

claudia_bolch — Wed, 23 Jul 2014 13:38:07 GMT

Haha ooops, I meant "normal" people, not normal "people"

Re: Poll: Development in ABAP Objects / Webdynpro vs. classical Dynpro

Former Member — Wed, 23 Jul 2014 13:41:23 GMT

Hey Suhas,

thank you very much !!

thats much better than a discussion!!

regards,

Christoph