topic Re: Question Group function in Application Development and Automation Discussions

Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:03:15 GMT

Hi, i have a doubt about function groups...

I have three functions that belongs the same Function group X.

When i want transport the second function, system returns me that is impossible because i don´t have the other two functions in the include...

The include has this view:

LMY_GROUP_FUNCTIONXX

and for each function created there are an lMY_GROUP_FUNCTIONXX.. and in the header:

"*****************************************************************

THIS FILE IS GENERATED BY THE FUNCTION LIBRARY. *
NEVER CHANGE IT MANUALLY, PLEASE! *

*****************************************************************"

My question is:

Can i upload only one of this functions, there aren´t independet?

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:11:54 GMT

Was the function group ever transported or you are trying to transport just the second function module without transporting the function group first?

Vikranth

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:16:14 GMT

Thanks for reply...

My group function is in the next environment... But two functions no...

GROUP_FUNCTION -- YES

-- FUNCTION 1 -- YES

-- FUNCTION 2 -- NO

-- FUNCTION 3 -- NO

-- FUNCTION 4 -- My next function for the environment

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:17:35 GMT

Hi ,

You will have to transport the function group as well along with your function module.

If you don't have any link / dependency among these two and this third function module then why dont you make them in separate function group , so that you will not have any issue in transporting them.

Hope this is Helpful.

Regards,

Uma Dave

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:22:27 GMT

Hi UmaDave, you´re rigth... but i don´t understand why i´m forced to follow the order of creation of my functions...

It´is very strict... if my header is created...

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 08:26:56 GMT

HI iki ,

I didnt understand your question above.

what order you are pointing to.

Simply see if you can take out that function module and put in other function group so that you can transport without any issue.

Regards,

Uma Dave

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 10:51:23 GMT

Ok, i break up relationship between my old group and my function...

I create a new group and now works fine...

However still i don´t understand this relationships and his dependences...

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 11:07:36 GMT

Ok.. let me explain you that ,

See any function module in ABAP can not exist without a function group.

So a function module becomes a king of component in that particular function group.

so one thing about transport ,

You need to transport all the objects ,

so you can not simply transport functionn module withput function group.

Now regarding the other two function modules.

when you transport function group , you should include all the components which are part of that function group.

This is how your function module transportation becomes dependent on these two other function module. If they would have been in other function group then no dependency and hence no issues.

Hope it clarifies your doubt.

Regards,

Uma Dave

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 11:44:44 GMT

A function group is a program, named like SAPLZnnnnn with includes. SAP executes the named includes...the "glue" that puts it all together are the TOP and the XXX includes. The entire function group (program) is always loaded into SAP memory on the first call of a FM named in the program....

To correct problems with transported FM's, etc., one need merely retransport the (syntax-error-free) function group.

Re: Question Group function

Former Member — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 13:07:13 GMT

Ok, thanks for reply... But like in other languages i think is better do independet function modules between they... not independent with his header...

Thanks again