topic Re: something wrong about workbench request and client-independent in Application Development and Automation Discussions

something wrong about workbench request and client-independent

Former Member — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 03:48:10 GMT

hi all.

"Changes to cross-client Customizing objects and to Repository objects are recorded in Workbench requests" This is my understanding of workbench request.

i got a issue，i do a change in the DEV, and system returned "Prompt for transportable workbench request", and i transport this CR to client 100, but i can not see this in client 300.

then i fount this change is a client-dependent change. i need to transport it to client 300.

I DO NOT KNOW WHY THIS CLIENT-DEPENDENT CHANGE NAMED WORKBENCH REQUEST, can anyone tell what's wrong? and how can i recognise a change is A CLIENT-DEPENDENT OR A CLIENT-INDEPENDENT?

HELP...

thanks, best regards.

Re: something wrong about workbench request and client-independent

Nawanandana — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 04:18:30 GMT

Client dependent -- which you made / change in one client and it will reflect to all clients .

Client independent -- which you made / change in one client and is limited within that client only .

but in ur thing you have to chk the Transport routes (T-Code- STMS) in thre you have to give the transport path.

Or check the SCC4 configration.

regard

nawa

Re: something wrong about workbench request and client-independent

Former Member — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 05:04:47 GMT

hi nawa,thank you for your replay.

i think you got them confused.

Client dependent data is visible only when you logon to that specific client,

Client independent data is visible across all the clients of a system.

and i know what is the different between workbench request and customizting request.

it should be a customizing request,because this change is a client-dependent change.

but system returned a workbench request dialog box.

I am really confused.

Re: something wrong about workbench request and client-independent

GauthamV — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 05:07:38 GMT

Objects like Sap scripts are client dependent that are generated in workbench

request and which need to be transported

manually to other clients for testing purposes using SCC1 transaction.

Re: something wrong about workbench request and client-independent

Former Member — Tue, 17 Nov 2009 05:37:10 GMT

Hi,

Transport request is prompted, so that change goes from one system to another system (eg: dev to testing/quality)

But in DEV system itself, there can be 2 clients like 100 and 300.

You would need to manually copy in 300 client , some customizing changes/table entries.

Transport request in such cases, will only take changes from one system to another.

I dont think there is any way to understand, whether we need to make the same change, in other client also.

You need to just cross-check, after making change in 100.

Regards,

Nisha Vengal.