topic Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi in Application Development and Automation Discussions

bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 04:43:04 GMT

Plese give me the following information.

1) wt is the difference between BAPIRETURN, BAPIRET1 and BAPIRET2?

2) wt is the diff. between an RFC-enabled fm and BAPI ?

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 04:45:57 GMT

Hi Christopher,

1. wt is the diff. between an RFC-enabled fm and BAPI ?

Not much.

BAPI is having a corresponding business object

which is REGISTERED in Sap Repository.

2. Where as RFC-enabled FM

is just a normal FM

which can be called from outside the SYSTEM

using RFC concept (DESTINATION )

(The confusion is created bcos

BAPI concept (business object conept)

are implemented in SAP

using FM Only (which are RFC Enabled)

and the name of the FM starts with BAPI_*.

)

regards,

amit m.

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 04:52:38 GMT

Hello Amit !

As u said, there is no differnce..if i select rfc-enabled and give a name as ztest(fm name) will it behave as BAPI ??(without giving BAPI_* as a name?)

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 04:58:06 GMT

Hi Christopher,

BAPI is an interface of a business object based on the OO (object oriented) concept. You can find all the Business objects using tran code SWO1.

Whereas remote function call could be any function module (non business object interfaces) defined in a remote system which you can call specifying the remote destination. For this you will have to define the destination name in the RFC definition (SM59).

Example: Function module to read a sales order from SAP system which can be called from CRM system

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:03:23 GMT

Hi again,

1. YES, Definitely it will behave like BAPI.

2. The sap concept of

naming function modules (related to business object)

and naming them as BAPI*

is JUST FOR IDENTIFIECATION PURPOSE,

and nothing else.

We can give ANY NAME.

regards,

amit m.

Message was edited by: Amit Mittal

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:07:14 GMT

Thanx chandrika.

can u tell wt is diff. between the 3 str.( BAPIRETURN, BAPIRET1 nd BAPIRET2 ) ?

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

hymavathi_oruganti — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:08:12 GMT

1.all the three are return paramter structures.

the difference is BAPIRET1 has 1 field ID more than BAPIRETURN and BAPIRET2 has some more fields like ROW, COLUMN etc. the purpose of all the three are same.

2.BAPI is an interface which uses RFC.

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:15:14 GMT

Hi hymavathi,

can we use any of the three. How can we know, in what case we have to use BAPIRET1 or BAPIRET2?

Can u plz tell me difference other than the fields in these structures ?

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

hymavathi_oruganti — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:23:18 GMT

u can use BAPIRET2 only as it also gives LOGICAL SYSTEM NAME, etc details.

so as BAPIRET2 satisfies more requirements u can always use BAPIRET2.

BAPIRET2 can be said as improvement of other two

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:28:07 GMT

Thank u so much Hymavathi,

can u please much more clear with RFC fm and BAPI ? I m still in confusion with this ?

Amit posted good answer but can u elaborate and explain me in detail !

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

hymavathi_oruganti — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:32:05 GMT

hi,

The procedure to create BAPI

1.in se11 create a structure of type zbapi or ybapi.

2. se37 , create a fn module of type REMOTE and release

3. in SW01, CREATE AN OBJECT/INTERFACE TYPE AND ASSIGN THE FN MODULE

TO THE METHOD INSIDE (THIS IS THE BAPI)

4. NOW GO TO TCODE BAPI AND CHECK THE BAPI CRETAED.

now the second step can be replaced by METHODS TOO. but

as RFC is efficient, we are assigning RFC to the BAPI.

so BAPI uses RFC. BAPI is an interface which uses RFC .

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

Former Member — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:40:18 GMT

hi hymavathi,

in step 3,

wt is diff. between object type and interface type?

Re: bapi doubt ...difference rfc and bapi

hymavathi_oruganti — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 05:49:58 GMT

hi Christopher,

OBJECTTYPE/ INTERFACE TYPE both are technical names give to BOR.

but category object type, is related to work flow.

interface type , we assign RFC.